Call Us Anytime

Amped Plumbing Blog · Emergency Plumbing

Toilet Overflowing? How to Stop It and What to Do Next

By Joe Norton, Owner, Amped Plumbing · Warr Acres, OK · OK Plumbing Contractor Lic #049194
Reviewed by Mickey Lyons, licensed plumbing contractor
Published March 22, 2024 · Updated November 17, 2026

Short answer: To stop an overflowing toilet, take the lid off the tank and push the rubber flapper down over the hole at the bottom, then turn the shutoff valve behind the toilet clockwise until it stops. Do not flush again. Once the water is off, plunge it. If other drains are backing up too, the problem is the sewer line, not the toilet.

Stop the water: three moves

  1. Do not flush again. Each flush adds a tank of water to the bowl.
  2. Close the flapper. Lift the tank lid and press the rubber flapper at the bottom of the tank down onto its seat. The tank water is clean.
  3. Shut the valve. Turn the valve on the wall or floor behind the toilet clockwise until it stops. If it will not turn, lift the float in the tank to stop the fill, or shut off the main.

Clear the clog

  • Wait for the water level in the bowl to drop.
  • Use a flange plunger, the kind with the extra sleeve on the bottom. Seal it over the drain and push and pull steadily. How to use a plunger shows the technique.
  • If plunging does not clear it, a toilet auger is the next tool.
  • Do not pour chemical drain cleaner into a toilet.
Amped Plumbing tech working on a toilet in a bathroom

Clean up safely

  • Wear gloves. Treat the water as contaminated.
  • Mop it up quickly so it does not get under flooring or through to the ceiling below.
  • Disinfect the floor, the base of the toilet and anything the water touched.
  • Wash or discard soaked rugs and towels.

Is it the toilet or the sewer line?

Just the toilet: only that toilet is affected, and the sinks and tub nearby drain normally.

The sewer line: any of these point to the main line.

  • Water comes up in the tub or shower when the toilet is flushed.
  • More than one toilet or drain is slow or backing up.
  • The toilet gurgles when the washing machine drains.
  • It overflowed without anyone flushing it.

If it is the sewer line, stop using water in the house and see what to do in a sewer backup.

Why it keeps happening

  • Too much paper, or wipes. Wipes labeled flushable do not break down like toilet paper.
  • Something dropped in: a toy, a cap, a hygiene product.
  • An older low-flow toilet with a weak flush.
  • A partial blockage or roots further down the line.

More in why does my toilet keep clogging.

When to call a plumber

  • Plunging and an auger do not clear it.
  • The signs point to the sewer line.
  • It is the only toilet in the home.
  • It overflows again within days.

Amped Plumbing answers day or night; see emergency plumbing and toilet repair and replacement.

Toilet will not clear, or drains are backing up?

Call Amped Plumbing. We answer day or night across the Oklahoma City metro.

Common questions

How do I stop a toilet from overflowing?

Push the flapper in the tank closed, then turn the shutoff valve behind the toilet clockwise until it stops. Do not flush again.

Why is my toilet overflowing when I did not flush?

Water coming up without a flush usually means the main sewer line is blocked and water from elsewhere in the house is backing up.

Is an overflowing toilet an emergency?

It is if you cannot stop it, if it is the only toilet in the home, or if other drains are backing up too.

About the author: Joe Norton is the owner of Amped Plumbing. He started the business in 2008, working out of a single truck, and built it on hard work and word of mouth. More about Amped Plumbing.

Amped Plumbing is a licensed plumbing company (OK Plumbing Contractor License #049194, held by Mickey Lyons) based in Warr Acres and serving the Oklahoma City metro, including Edmond, Moore, Yukon, Norman, Bethany and Nichols Hills.

Need cameras or an alarm system? Visit Amped Security →