Call Us Anytime

Amped Plumbing Blog · Water Quality

Water Filter vs. Water Softener: What Is the Difference?

By Joe Norton, Owner, Amped Plumbing · Warr Acres, OK · OK Plumbing Contractor Lic #049194
Reviewed by Mickey Lyons, licensed plumbing contractor
Updated November 17, 2026

Short answer: A water softener removes the calcium and magnesium that make water hard and cause scale. A water filter removes other things: sediment, chlorine, iron, taste and odor. Neither does the other’s job. Homes with hard water and another issue, such as iron or chlorine taste, often need both.

What a water softener does

A softener swaps hardness minerals for a small amount of sodium using resin beads, then rinses the beads with salt water. The result is water that does not leave scale in your water heater, pipes and fixtures, and that lets soap lather. It does not remove chlorine, sediment or most iron. How softeners work is covered in the complete guide to water softeners.

What a water filter does

“Filter” covers several different devices:

  • Sediment filters catch sand, rust and grit.
  • Carbon filters reduce chlorine, taste and smell.
  • Iron filters remove iron that stains and tastes metallic.

None of them removes hardness. See benefits of a whole-house filtration system.

Water softener and filtration tanks side by side

Which problem do you have?

  • White scale on fixtures, spots on dishes, soap scum, dry skin: hard water. Softener.
  • Orange or brown stains, metallic taste: iron. Iron filter.
  • Chlorine or pool smell and taste: carbon filter.
  • Grit in the aerators, cloudy water: sediment filter.
  • Rotten-egg smell: sulfur, usually on a well; needs specific treatment.

When you need both

Hard water plus iron is common on wells around Oklahoma City. Iron fouls softener resin, so an iron filter is installed ahead of the softener. Hard city water plus a chlorine taste is the other common pairing: a softener for the scale and a carbon filter for the taste.

Start with a water test

Guessing leads to the wrong equipment. A test for hardness and iron tells you which of these you have and how much, which also decides the size of the system. Amped Plumbing installs water softeners and sediment, carbon and iron filters; see water softener installation, and does Oklahoma City have hard water for what hard water does to plumbing.

Softener, filter or both?

Amped Plumbing tests your water, tells you which one it calls for, and installs both.

Common questions

Do I need a water softener or a water filter?

A softener if your problem is scale, spots and soap scum. A filter if it is sediment, chlorine taste or iron staining. A water test tells you which.

Can a water softener remove iron?

Only small amounts, and iron shortens the life of the resin. Noticeable iron needs an iron filter.

Is softened water filtered?

No. Softening removes hardness minerals only. Chlorine, sediment and most other things pass through.

About the author: Joe Norton is the owner of Amped Plumbing. He started the business in 2008, working out of a single truck, and built it on hard work and word of mouth. More about Amped Plumbing.

Amped Plumbing is a licensed plumbing company (OK Plumbing Contractor License #049194, held by Mickey Lyons) based in Warr Acres and serving the Oklahoma City metro, including Edmond, Moore, Yukon, Norman, Bethany and Nichols Hills.

Need cameras or an alarm system? Visit Amped Security →